Investigations
121 stories
PubPeer Comments Ran a Median of 10 Months Ahead of Retractions. Cassava Answered Its Critics With a Lawsuit.
Retracted papers drew comments on PubPeer a median of 10 months before journals pulled them. The Cassava file shows what can happen to the people doing the commenting, and how much of the institutional record never becomes public.
InvestigationsElsevier Has Spent 11 Months on a Plagiarism Complaint Without Posting an Expression of Concern
A Bangladeshi forest study and a Chinese soil study report identical mean incomes for identical stakeholder groups. The authors asked to retract in December 2025. Elsevier's own policy provides for a warning notice, and none is on record.
InvestigationsThe Lancet Countdown Wants a Global Health Emergency Built to Last Decades
WHO's polio emergency has had to be re-justified every three months since 2014. Climate researchers now want a WHO emergency instrument built for decades, and nothing published so far says who would ever end it.
InvestigationsBioengineered Retracted 119 Papers in October, and Taylor & Francis Answered With a 16-Month-Old Note
More than 1,000 papers in one Taylor & Francis journal carry an "under investigation" notice. The publisher has retracted 255, and nothing on the record says how the two counts connect.
InvestigationsArgentina Logged 32 Violations in Pfizer's Maternal RSV Trial 20 Months Before the FDA Approved It for Pregnancy
Inspectors found a 16-year-old enrolled under a protocol that required women 18 or older in Argentina, and newborn serious events misclassified or left out of hospital charts. The fine came two years after approval.
InvestigationsThe NIH Hospital Board Chair Who Rebuked Kennedy's Vaccine-Injury Clinic Has Counseled Pfizer, Merck and Sanofi
The Times quoted Jack Leslie's rebuke of the NIH vaccine-injury clinic and called him a former PR chairman. It left out his current Weber Shandwick job and the deputy director's answer.
InvestigationsMen Lose 16 Percent More Healthy Years, and Few Governments Have a Plan for Them
Excess male death took off with the generations born after 1880. The Lancet now concedes many men are 'failing to thrive,' while key UN frameworks still read 'gender' as women and Washington has no office for men's health.
InvestigationsClinicians Have Asked an Ad-Funded AI 271 Million Questions, and Most Patients Can't Say Whether It Touched Their Care
Sixty percent of Americans are uncomfortable with AI in their diagnosis and treatment, and 46 percent can't say whether a provider has used it in their care. One clinical AI platform, paid for partly by drug and device ads, has already logged 271 million clinician queries.
InvestigationsThree Sydney Space-Physics Papers Outlasted a 2023 Fabrication Finding Against Their First Author
A 2023 Sydney inquiry found Joachim Schmidt fabricated a figure in an unpublished manuscript. Journals now say figures in three of his published papers were likely fabricated too, and those retractions began with an anonymous complaint to the publisher in 2024.
InvestigationsFrom 'Vaccine Hesitancy' to 'Trust': Five Years of NIH Insiders Grading Vaccine-Injury Research by Public Reaction
In 2021 Francis Collins warned that a paper on nerve symptoms after COVID vaccination would feed 'vaccine hesitancy.' This month the NIH hospital board's chair warned the new clinic's findings would be dismissed either way. Of decided federal COVID countermeasure claims, 98.4 percent were denied.
InvestigationsA Melbourne Gender Study Scored 234 Children on Their Transition Goals and Left Wellbeing Out
Researchers at Melbourne's Royal Children's Hospital sorted 234 children aged 8 to 17 by how many of their name, pronoun and appearance goals they had reached. Their cohort tracks mental health, and the paper did not analyze it as an outcome.
InvestigationsOven Gloves Bought From a Top Online Retailer Tested 89 Percent Asbestos
A private citizen asked two Italian mineralogists whether a cheap pair of heat-resistant gloves labeled Made in China was asbestos. The lab answered 89 percent chrysotile by weight, and the listing never said so.
InvestigationsWomen Who Cleaned Lost Lung Function at a Pace Compared to Smoking 10 to 20 Cigarettes a Day
Over 20 years, women who cleaned at home or for a living lost lung function faster than women who didn't. Tested scented products gave off carcinogens their labels never named, and single-chemical safety limits weren't built for the mixture under your sink.
InvestigationsWe Were Told to Disinfect Everything. The Chlorine Gas Calls Never Came Back Down.
US poison centers logged a 39.8 percent jump in chlorine gas exposures the year disinfection messaging peaked. Through 2022 here and 2025 in France, the numbers never came back down.
InvestigationsThe WHO Asked the World to Listen to Mental Health Patients. By Its Own Count, Half Were Committed Against Their Will.
The WHO built this year's World Mental Health Day around putting patients in charge of policy. Its own 2024 atlas reports 49% of reported admissions are involuntary and nearly a quarter of hospital stays run past a year.
InvestigationsThe Weedkiller RFK Jr. Blamed for Chronic Disease Is Now a National-Security Asset
RFK Jr. once called glyphosate a likely culprit in America's chronic disease epidemic. As health secretary he defended a Defense Production Act order boosting it, and his own base is in revolt.
InvestigationsThe Nerve Chip You Inject Through a Needle Hasn't Eased Anyone's Pain Yet
Built with no battery and no wires and placed through a needle, the seed-sized chip could avoid some of the hardware failures behind today's spinal cord stimulator recalls. Nobody has yet shown it relieves pain in people.
InvestigationsThe Mucosal Immunologist His Own University Declared No COVID Expert
Robert Clancy spent his career on the airway immunity a shot in the arm was never built to raise. When the transmission promise collapsed, Newcastle had already ruled him no COVID expert.
InvestigationsThe CDC's Flu-Shot Effectiveness Figures Come Out of a Regression Model, Not a Trial
The CDC's 41 percent flu-shot figure for seniors comes from a regression run on sick clinic patients, and the study's own tables show timing, exclusion and healthy-vaccinee biases built into it.
InvestigationsThe Byline Broker Signed Its Sales Pitch With a London Oncologist's Name
Springer Journals Online sold co-author slots on papers it said were nearly through review at Elsevier, Wiley and Springer Nature, and signed the pitch with a cancer researcher's name. Its website is gone. The manuscripts have not been publicly identified.
InvestigationsThe 33 Infections the CDC's 90 Percent Vaccine Number Left Out
In March 2021 the CDC announced that mRNA vaccines cut infection risk by 90 percent. Its own report set aside 33 infections that struck in the days after the shot, and a peer-reviewed critique shows how that counting rule can make a useless vaccine look 48 percent effective.
InvestigationsNew York Keeps 51 Cents of Every Dollar Its Gamblers Lose, and the Addiction Tripwire It Just Proposed Doesn't Trip Until a $10,000 Single-Day Deposit
New York taxes sportsbooks on the money bettors lose at 51 percent and has booked $3.89 billion since 2022. The at-risk rules its Gaming Commission proposed October 9 adopt New Jersey's model, whose deposit trigger DraftKings already meets: more than $10,000 in a single day.
InvestigationsMedical Chatbots Reached African Patients Before the Benchmark Meant to Grade Them
More than 500,000 people in Kenya texted an AI maternal-health line in 2024. The money to test tools like it arrived in 2026, and the global yardstick to grade them is still being built.
InvestigationsYour Country's Estimated Heat Death Toll Depends on Which Heat Metric the Modelers Picked
Japan recorded 1,522 heatstroke deaths in 2020. One model called that unusually high; a better-fitting one put it inside the expected range. Europe's estimated heat tolls bend to the same kind of choice.