Excess male death is younger than most people assume. A 2015 PNAS analysis covered 13 wealthy countries and 1,763 birth cohorts going back to 1800. In the cohorts born before 1880, middle-aged men died at roughly 1.1 times the rate of women, which is close to parity. The ratio climbed once the generations born after 1880 reached their fifties. At age 50 it was 1.39 for people born 1880 to 1899, 1.68 for those born 1900 to 1919, and 1.90 for those born 1920 to 1935.
| Group | Value (ratio) |
|---|---|
| Born 1880 to 1899 | 1.39 |
| Born 1900 to 1919 | 1.68 |
| Born 1920 to 1935 | 1.90 |
Many men are failing to thrive
The mechanism tells you why the problem has lasted so long. As infections killed fewer people, female mortality between ages 40 and 90 fell about 70 percent faster than male mortality, and the deaths that remained increasingly came from the diseases of middle age that hit men hardest. Smoking accounts for about 30 percent of excess male deaths at ages 50 to 70 among those born 1900 to 1935. Once tobacco is taken out, a large excess is still there, particularly from cardiovascular disease. So the male disadvantage is a product of modern life rather than a fixed fact of biology, and that makes it the kind of problem public health exists to bring down.
A century later, The Lancet has said so. “Many men are failing to thrive,” begins an editorial in the journal’s October 31 issue. It traces men’s shorter lives back to the 19th century and notes that the gap has kept widening, though unevenly from region to region. It also reports that men worldwide lose 16 percent more disability-adjusted life-years than women, a measure that counts healthy years lost to early death and to disability together. The flagship journal of the global health establishment has made this admission at last, roughly 140 years after the first post-1880 birth cohorts.
Its lateness is easier to understand once you see how little the global numbers have moved. In a commentary in the Bulletin of the World Health Organization last year, Morna Cornell of the University of Cape Town put 2023 life expectancy at birth at 71 years for men and 76 for women, a gap she notes has persisted since 1950. The piece ran in WHO’s journal and is not a statement of WHO policy. Its argument is that on health outcomes “men are clearly the furthest behind,” and that international agencies, funders and national programs have mostly looked elsewhere.
Where the healthy years go
The burden has been mapped in detail. A Global Burden of Disease analysis in The Lancet Public Health, funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, found that males carried more health loss than females in 13 of the 20 leading causes of disease burden in 2021. The largest gap was ischemic heart disease, the same disease the PNAS team followed through the birth cohorts. It cost males 3,599 age-standardized healthy years per 100,000, compared with 1,987 for females.
Diabetes shows the trend over time. In 1990 males lost 56.1 more healthy years per 100,000 than females. By 2021 the male excess was 142.7, about two and a half times as large. Road injuries, stroke, chronic respiratory disease and liver disease also fall more heavily on men. Women’s excess burden comes from a different set of conditions, led by low back pain, depression and headache disorders, which mostly disable rather than kill. Women tend to lose healthy years to illness, and men tend to lose them to early death.
COVID-19 followed the same pattern on a larger scale. The virus cost males 3,978 healthy years per 100,000 against 2,211 for females, and in sub-Saharan Africa the figures were 10,559 against 5,565. Even so, the GBD team found that around 60 percent of countries did not consistently break down their COVID-19 data by sex. In most of the world, then, the official reporting during the pandemic could not consistently show which sex the virus was hitting harder.
Gender, filed under women
Cornell’s commentary explains that blind spot. She writes that many global bodies “continue to explicitly equate gender with women,” and gives three examples: the UN Inter-Agency Network on Women and Gender Equality, the UNAIDS operational plan on women, girls, gender equality and HIV, and Sustainable Development Goal 5. One review she cites looked at 37 regional and global sexual and reproductive health policy documents and found only five that set any target for men. If a framework counts women’s outcomes and seldom counts men’s, it will record progress for women and have almost nothing to report about men.
Few governments have done better. Ireland wrote the first national men’s health policy, and Cornell says it is still the only one to have been formally evaluated. The evaluation credited it with substantial gains in community programs, research and training. It also found that the recommendations were too many and too broad, which limited what the policy could do about structural risk factors. Australia, Brazil, Iran, Malaysia, Mongolia and South Africa have since adopted policies, along with the WHO European Region and the Canadian province of Quebec. England launched its first Men’s Health Strategy on International Men’s Day, November 19, 2025. It commits £3.6 million over three years to suicide prevention projects for middle-aged men, £3 million to community men’s health programs, and £200,000 to a trial targeting cardiovascular deaths linked to cocaine and alcohol. Three-quarters of suicides in England are men.
Cornell adds one more figure that a national average hides. In the UK, life expectancy differs by 27 years between groups of men depending on socioeconomic status. That spread is far larger than the gap between the sexes, and it shows that the burden does not fall on men equally.
Washington has an office for women
The United States has no national men’s health policy, and its own gap has a long history. According to STAT’s 2025 reporting, American women outlived men by 1.8 years in 1921 and by 7.7 years in 1979. The gap then closed to 4.8 years by 2010, after which a JAMA Internal Medicine study led by Brandon Yan found it had grown back to 5.8 years by 2021, the largest since 1996. COVID-19 was the biggest contributor between 2019 and 2021, followed by unintentional injuries and poisonings, mostly drug overdoses, and then suicide. Before the pandemic the main contributors were unintentional injuries, diabetes, suicide, homicide and heart disease. By 2023 the gap had come back down to 5.3 years, which is still above where it stood in 2010.
Many of these deaths are preventable. National Safety Council figures cited by STAT show that men accounted for 67 percent of the 222,698 preventable injury deaths in 2023. The Affordable Care Act requires insurers to cover an annual well-woman visit at no cost. Men receive the general list of covered screenings, but there is no required well-man visit to go with it. “We think about men’s health as a problem of men’s misbehavior,” Derek Griffith, a professor of population health and health equity at the University of Pennsylvania, told STAT. Institutions find that framing convenient because it puts the failure on the patient instead of the system. The causes the data actually identify are a pandemic whose sex skew most countries didn’t consistently report, an overdose wave, rising metabolic disease, and a cardiovascular excess that has been killing middle-aged men for more than a century. Blaming men’s behavior doesn’t account for those. “There’s nothing inevitable or inexorable about the lifespan gender gap,” said Ronald Henry, president of the Men’s Health Network.
HHS has had an Office on Women’s Health since 1991 and has never had a counterpart for men. The State of Men’s Health Act would change that. It would create an Office of Men’s Health inside HHS and require a Government Accountability Office report on the state of men’s health within one year of enactment. Sen. Ruben Gallego, an Arizona Democrat, introduced the Senate version in July with Kansas Republican Roger Marshall as a co-sponsor. A bipartisan House version filed earlier this year has the backing of Assistant Secretary for Health Brian Christine, a urologist. Supporters told STAT the bill could take years to pass. With the gap documented in national mortality tables since 1921, the next move is Congress’s, and the thing to watch is whether either chamber brings the bill to a committee vote before this session ends in January.
Sources
- The Lancet: Editorial, “Improving men’s health in a changing world” (October 31, 2026)
- The Lancet Public Health: sex differences in the top 20 causes of disease burden, GBD 2021 (news release, 2024)
- Bulletin of the World Health Organization: Cornell, “Men’s health policies: long overdue” (2025)
- PNAS: Beltrán-Sánchez, Finch and Crimmins, “Twentieth century surge of excess adult male mortality” (2015)
- Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health: Yan et al., widening US gender gap in life expectancy, JAMA Internal Medicine (2023)
- STAT: How research ignores men dying younger (2025)
- STAT: Bipartisan bill filed for a federal Office of Men’s Health (2026)
- Healthcare Management UK: England’s first Men’s Health Strategy (2025)